Base of thumb arthritis: Expert insight on symptoms, diagnosis and treatment

Written in association with: Miss Sally-Anne Phillips
Published:
Edited by: Sophie Kennedy

In this informative article, revered consultant hand and wrist surgeon Miss Sally-Anne Phillips sheds light on the most common symptoms of base of thumb arthritis and how the condition is diagnosed. The leading specialist also discusses the various treatment options and reveals when surgery is indicated.

 

 

What is base of thumb arthritis?

 

It is a common ageing process where there is the loss of cartilage at the thumb carpometacarpal joint (CMCJ) which is thought to occur due to attenuation of a ligament in the thumb leading to instability. Previous trauma or accident to the thumb can also lead to abnormal forces through the joint causing loss of cartilage.

 

What are the typical symptoms?

 

Base of thumb arthritis can result in symptoms of thumb swelling, pain on movement and difficulties with tasks that load the thumb, such as opening jars, wringing out clothes, turning a key in a door or writing.

 

What are the risk factors for developing base of thumb arthritis?

 

There is a greater incidence in Caucasian women and in those with prior trauma, a history of osteoarthritis, hypermobility syndromes or an increased body mass index (BMI).

 

How is base of thumb arthritis diagnosed?

 

It is diagnosed with symptoms of pain in the thumb or wrist or difficulty using the thumb for grasping and loading tasks. In examination of the thumb, there are signs of pain over the carpometacarpal joint (CMCJ) and reduced range of movement of the thumb joint. The bones at the bottom of the thumb may become prominent in advanced disease. X-rays can confirm the presence of arthritis but they have been shown not to correlate with the severity of patient’s symptoms.

 

What are the available treatment options for base of thumb arthritis?

 

Simple painkillers or anti-inflammatory medication and a thumb wrap support can improve symptoms initially. Avoiding activities that aggravate the pain is also recommended. If pain persists then a joint injection of local anaesthetic and steroid can improve things. This is a temporary measure which has a shorter duration of action the more frequently it is given.

 

Depending on the severity of the arthritis, patient comorbidites and lifestyle, surgery can vary from:

  • Insertion of a joint spacer to act as a buffer between the joint surfaces of the base of the metacarpal and trapezium
  • An osteotomy (a bone cut) to the metacarpal bone to realign it
  • Trapeziectomy, a removal of the trapezium bone which makes up the CMCJ, with or without a ligament suspension
  • Joint replacement of the CMCJ
  • Fusion of the bones that make up the CMCJ joint
  • Denervation of nerves to the CMCJ, where the nerves to the thumb are divided to allow pain free movement even though the arthritis continues to progress.

 

What is the prognosis and long-term management for base of thumb arthritis?

 

Overall the osteoarthritis will burn itself out with time. The pain is a temporary feature although this may take years rather than months to improve. Surgery is often viewed as the last option if pain and restriction remain after conservative treatment fails.

 

 

If you are suffering with symptoms of base of thumb arthritis and wish to schedule a consultation with Miss Phillips, you can do so by visiting her Top Doctors profile.

By Miss Sally-Anne Phillips
Orthopaedic surgery

Miss Sally-Anne Phillips is a leading trauma and consultant surgeon based in Stirling who specialises exclusively in hand and wrist surgery for the treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome, Dupuytren’s disease, trigger finger, hand and wrist sport injuries, and arthritis of the hand and wrist. She has particular expertise in arthroplasty hand surgery and is also qualified to perform medicolegal work. Alongside her NHS work at Monklands and Wishaw Hospitals, Miss Phillips currently sees patients at Kings Park Hospital.

Miss Phillips qualified from University College London in 2001 and undertook her basic surgical and orthopaedic training in London, Plymouth, Dunfermline and Edinburgh, where she worked at the prestigious Edinburgh Orthopaedic Unit. She became a fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh in 2015 and completed an observational hand fellowship in Boston, USA that same year.

Miss Phillips was awarded the prestigious Training Interface Group fellowship in hand surgery a year later, practising with hand specialists in Newcastle Upon Tyne, before going on to obtain her Diploma in Hand Surgery in 2020. This certification, awarded by The British Society for Surgery of the Hand in partnership with the University of Manchester covers the whole length of hand surgery, recognising practical knowledge and excellent quality.

Currently, Miss Phillips is one of the very few surgeons performing incisionless carpal tunnel decompression, as well as carpometacarpal joint replacement surgery. You can read a case study here of a successfully performed carpometacarpal joint replacement by Miss Phillips.

Further to her highly-specialised surgical practice, Miss Phillips is closely involved in clinical research and medical education. She holds an MD from the University of Edinburgh and is the author of various papers and abstracts published in peer-reviewed journals. Between 2019 and 2022, she also served as a primary investigator for the DISC trial, a multi-centred study on the comparison between collagenase injections and surgical fasciectomy for Dupuytren’s contracture.

With a passion for complex hand anatomy and bespoke treatment, Miss Phillips believes in a detailed patient-centred approach to improve and achieve the utmost hand function after surgery. 

View Profile

Overall assessment of their patients


  • Related procedures
  • Platelet-rich plasma
    Ozone therapy
    Botulinum toxin (Botox™)
    Abnormal gait
    Elbow
    Epicondylitis (tennis elbow)
    Elbow Pain
    Nerve Compression elbow
    Median nerve compression
    Radial nerve compression
    This website uses our own and third-party Cookies to compile information with the aim of improving our services, to show you advertising related to your preferences as well analysing your browsing habits. You can change your settings HERE.