What are the advantages of hybrid closed loop insulin pumps?

Written in association with: Dr Natasha Patel
Published:
Edited by: Conor Dunworth

Living with diabetes necessitates constant vigilance and meticulous management to ensure a healthy and fulfilling life. Over time, advancements in medical technology have introduced innovative solutions to simplify and enhance this management process. One notable advancement is the hybrid closed loop insulin pump, commonly known as an artificial pancreas. In this article, leading consultant diabetologist Dr Natasha Patel delves into the advantages and disadvantages of this groundbreaking device, helping you make an informed decision regarding its suitability for yourself or your loved ones.

 

What are the advantages of hybrid closed loop pumps?

Hybrid closed loop pumps come with several advantages, including:

  • Automated insulin delivery: One of the most significant benefits of the closed loop insulin pump is its capacity for automating insulin delivery. This device employs continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) to monitor blood sugar levels in real time and adjusts insulin delivery accordingly. This minimises the need for manual interventions, reducing the risks of hyperglycaemia and hypoglycaemia.
  • Precise glucose control: The closed loop system is engineered to maintain blood sugar levels within a narrow range, diminishing the fluctuations that can contribute to diabetes-related complications over time. This precise glucose control can contribute to overall better health and a reduced risk of long-term complications.
  • Reduced burden and mental strain: Managing diabetes can be mentally and emotionally taxing. With a closed loop insulin pump, there is less necessity for constant insulin dosage calculations and concerns about potential blood sugar spikes or crashes. This can lead to a substantial reduction in the daily burden associated with diabetes management.
  • Enhanced quality of life: The automation provided by the closed loop system offers greater flexibility in daily activities and meal planning. Individuals can enjoy increased freedom without the constant need to structure their lives around insulin dosing schedules.

 

What are the disadvantages of hybrid closed loop pumps?

Hybrid closed loop pumps also come with a number of disadvantages. These include:

  • Learning curve: Transitioning to a closed loop system involves a learning curve. Users must acquaint themselves with the device's settings, comprehend its responses to various situations, and become proficient in interpreting glucose sensor data effectively. This initial adjustment period may necessitate time and patience.
  • Technology reliability: Like any technological device, closed loop insulin pumps are not immune to technical glitches or malfunctions. Relying on a machine for insulin delivery implies that any technical issues could have serious consequences. It is crucial to have contingency plans and be knowledgeable about reverting to manual insulin delivery if necessary.
  • Customisation challenges: Although closed loop systems are designed to adapt to various scenarios, they may not perfectly align with the unique needs of every individual. Fine-tuning settings and customising the system to accommodate personal insulin sensitivity can be a complex process requiring ongoing communication with healthcare professionals.
  • Constant attachment: Being attached to both a glucose sensor and the pump can be disheartening for some individuals.

 

 

The closed loop insulin pump marks a significant advancement in diabetes management technology, offering the potential for precise glucose control, reduced daily burdens, and an improved quality of life. Nevertheless, it is imperative to thoroughly evaluate the pros and cons before making a decision. Consultation with doctors, diabetes educators, and individuals experienced with the technology can provide valuable insights to assist in determining whether a closed loop system is the appropriate choice. Keep in mind that diabetes management is highly individualised, and the optimal approach will depend on your unique requirements, preferences, and lifestyle.

 

 

If you would like to book a consultation with Dr Natasha Patel, you can do so today via her Top Doctors profile.

By Dr Natasha Patel
Endocrinology, diabetes & metabolism

Dr Natasha Patel is a leading consultant diabetologist based in London who specialises in diabetes and acute medicine, including Type 1 and Type 2 diabetes, diabetes complications, and the use of diabetes technology. In addition to diabetes, her main areas of focus are also the thyroid gland and all aspects of functional medicine. Dr Patel sees patients through e-Consultation.

Dr Patel qualified from Imperial College London in 1999, having previously obtained a BSc (Hons) in Neurosciences in 1996. She took up a consultant post at St George’s Healthcare in 2008, and was soon named joint diabetes clinical director at Health Innovation Network, responsible for numerous projects across South London. Dr Patel became a fellow of the Royal College of Physicians in 2014 and was appointed as a consultant in diabetes at Guy’s and St Thomas’ a year later. She is also a Functional Medicine Practitioner with a holistic approach to the management of her patients.

Further to her clinical practice, Dr Patel is an experienced healthcare services professional. She is actively involved in several hospital and healthcare industry projects, and acts as a consultant for start ups, where she also uses her MBA knowledge.

View Profile

Overall assessment of their patients


  • Related procedures
  • Alopecia
    Hyperhidrosis
    Eating disorders
    Erectile dysfunction
    Menopause
    Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS)
    Hypertension (high blood pressure)
    Infertility
    Disorder of sexual desire of man
    Clinical nutrition
    This website uses our own and third-party Cookies to compile information with the aim of improving our services, to show you advertising related to your preferences as well analysing your browsing habits. You can change your settings HERE.